A year ago, 6% of consumers asked AI to recommend a local business. Today it’s 45%.
Let that sink in for a second. Because when I started my first business, the way customers found you looked very different.
Back when I launched my first consultancy, BREATHE, a typical client website was a $25,000 project. We’d spend weeks on the wireframe. Then weeks on the copy. Then what felt like an eternity on the build. And once it went live, the client kept it for years. Nobody was redoing a $25,000 investment every spring because a new font was trending.
Here’s the funny part. For all that money and effort, the website usually wasn’t how a business got found.
Mine certainly wasn’t. Business cards came first. Then cold calls, networking and word of mouth from the relationships I’d built coming up through corporate America. For almost ten years, out of Washington, D.C., Fort Knox and Alexandria, that’s how brands like Wrangler and The North Face found their way to me.
A person who knew me told another person about me. That was the whole marketing funnel.
How ChatGPT Became the New Referral
Referrals haven’t gone anywhere. For most of the small businesses I work with, word of mouth is still the best lead they’ll ever get.
But there’s a new kind of referral now, and it doesn’t come from a friend at dinner. It comes from a question typed into ChatGPT.
“Who carries Paige jeans near me?”
“Where can I find a cold plunge in Annapolis?”
“Is there an infrared sauna close by?”
That’s the 45% at work. And here’s the catch. My old referrals could vouch for me because they’d actually worked with me. AI can’t do that. It has never stood in your store or sat in your sauna. It can only repeat what your website, your listings and your reviews clearly say about you.
So if your message is vague, it used to cost you the sale. Now it can cost you the shortlist.
So how do you get recommended by ChatGPT? It isn’t a technical trick, and you don’t need to buy a mysterious “AI package.” It comes down to four StoryBrand principles that make your business easy for AI, and people, to recommend.
Principle #1: Say What You Sell
Clever is the enemy of found.
I see it all the time on beautiful websites. “Elevated living.” “A curated lifestyle experience.” “Where wellness meets you.” They sound lovely. They also tell a stranger (and a chatbot) absolutely nothing.
AI matches what people ask with what you clearly state. If someone asks for a boutique that carries Paige, the store whose site says “a women’s boutique in Annapolis carrying Paige denim” has a fighting chance. The store promising “a curated lifestyle experience” does not.
The people who study this are blunt about it. One local SEO firm warns that AI has no use for yet another page that says “We offer personalized care in a relaxing environment.” It wants specifics.
Try this: the five-second stranger test. Pull up your homepage and ask someone who doesn’t know your business three questions. What do we sell? Who is it for? Where are we? If they hesitate, so will ChatGPT.
Principle #2: Say What You Solve
In StoryBrand, the story starts with the customer’s problem, not your product. That’s a happy coincidence, because that’s exactly how people talk to AI.
Nobody types “sanctuary for the senses.” They type “how do I recover faster after a long run” or “what helps with restless sleep.” An infrared sauna studio that names sore muscles and restless sleep on its site speaks the same language as its future customer. The one with the poetic tagline is talking to itself.
The big beauty brands prove the point. ChatGPT recommended La Roche-Posay in 81% of facial skincare queries. That’s not luck. It’s a brand that has owned a clear problem for years. Another study found that the brands appearing most consistently in AI recommendations are those that own a particular space.
Try this: write down 20 to 30 questions your customers actually ask you, in their words. Then check whether your website answers them. Every unanswered question is a recommendation you’re handing to someone else.
Principle #3: Let Others Say It for You
This is where word of mouth and AI meet.
A great review is a referral in writing. And AI reads all of it.
Businesses that ChatGPT and Perplexity recommended averaged 133 Google reviews, versus 11 for those ignored. In beauty, third-party sites make up 96.1% of the sources in AI-generated recommendations. In other words, what other people say about you carries more weight than what you say about yourself. (Which, frankly, has always been true. AI just made it measurable.)
StoryBrand calls this authority. A guide earns trust through proof, not bragging.
Try this: when you ask happy customers for a review, ask them to mention the specific thing they loved. “The cold plunge.” “The personal shopper who found me the perfect dress.” Specific reviews match specific searches. “Great place!” doesn’t help anyone find you.
Principle #4: Say What to Do Next
Here’s the part most people miss. A recommendation only pays off if the person knows what to do when they land on your site.
The good news is that these visitors show up ready. Visitors referred from AI search platforms are three to five times more likely to convert than those from traditional search. They’ve already asked the question. AI already pointed them to you. Don’t make them hunt for the next step.
StoryBrand’s direct call to action is simple: one clear button that tells people exactly what to do. Book a session. Shop new arrivals. Plan your visit. Put it at the top of the page and repeat it as they scroll.
Try this: open your homepage on your phone. If you can’t find your main button with your thumb in three seconds, neither can your new customer.
Clarity Is the New Referral
When I started BREATHE, my reputation traveled from one person to the next over coffee and phone calls. It still does, thank goodness.
But now there’s another voice in the conversation, and it’s quoting you. Every word on your website is either helping it recommend you or giving it a reason to recommend someone else.
The businesses that win this shift won’t be the biggest ones or the ones with the fanciest websites. They’ll be the clearest ones.
So here’s your two-part challenge for this week.
First, ask, but ask like a stranger. If you’ve used ChatGPT to help with your marketing, it may already “know” your business and give you a flattering answer. So open a Temporary Chat (the button at the top of a new chat that’s a circle) and choose the unpersonalized option. Then skip your business name and ask questions your customer would ask: “Where can I find a cold plunge near Annapolis?”, “What boutiques near me carry Paige jeans?” or “Where can I find XX product near me”. Are you in the answer? If you are, does the description sound like you? For a true outside opinion, ask a friend to try it on her phone.
Second, check. If you have Google Analytics (it’s free, and if you don’t have it, set it up this week), go to Reports, then Acquisition, then Traffic acquisition. Look for a channel called “AI Assistant.” Google added it this year, and it shows how many visitors came to your site from tools like ChatGPT and Gemini. Keep in mind it only counts people who clicked through. The woman who heard about you from ChatGPT and walked straight into your store won’t show up, so treat the number as a floor, not a ceiling.
If what comes back sounds fuzzy, or worse, sounds like your competitor, that’s not a technology problem. It’s a messaging problem, and it’s very fixable.
When ChatGPT describes your business, do you like what it says?
If you ran this week’s challenge and didn’t love what came back, this is exactly what my Basics package is for. You walk away with a Brand Messaging Playbook: clear, consistent words for what you sell, what you solve, and what your customer should do next, ready for your website, your social media and every other place AI is reading about you. Take a look at The Basics here.

Comments +